The Recycler
  • G&G Feb 24 Masthead Banner
  • Biuromax Masthead web banner March 2024
  • Katun web banner December 2022 NEW

HP faces uphill battle as scanning class action prevails

August 11, 2023

In a significant legal setback for HP, a class action lawsuit targeting the company’s “all-in-one” printers has successfully overcome a motion to dismiss.

In a significant legal setback for HP (Hewlett-Packard), a class action lawsuit targeting the company’s “all-in-one” printers has successfully overcome a motion to dismiss. The case centres on allegations that these printers turn off scanning and faxing functions when ink levels are low, even though such functions do not inherently require ink. This ruling challenges HP’s defence strategy and raises broader questions about consumer rights and corporate accountability.

The plaintiffs, who filed the lawsuit, claim that HP’s printers contain a deliberate design flaw that forces users to purchase more ink cartridges than necessary. They argue that HP’s failure to disclose this limitation misleads consumers, ultimately driving up profits from ink cartridge sales. With printer ink costing anything up to €1,800 ($2,300) per litre, the financial burden on consumers is substantial, potentially overshadowing the prices of luxury goods like silver, caviar, and champagne.

U.S. District Court Judge Beth Freeman’s decision to allow the case to proceed underscores the validity of the plaintiffs’ claims. Judge Freeman acknowledged that the allegations in the amended complaint sufficiently outlined the defect’s cause and impact on printer performance. The judge only dismissed one claim under Minnesota’s Deceptive Trade Practices Act while upholding claims related to fraudulent omission, false claims, and unfair competition.

The lawsuit, originally filed in June 2022, initially faced dismissal due to a lack of clarity regarding the design flaw’s cause. However, an amended complaint provided a more comprehensive argument, referencing an HP message board post wherein a customer reported a printer malfunction due to a damaged ink cartridge. The plaintiffs argued that this defect was intentional and aimed at maximizing ink cartridge sales.

This ruling puts HP on the defensive, drawing attention to the tech giant’s previous legal disputes over printer-related matters.

In December 2020, the Italian Competition and Market Authority imposed a €10 million penalty on HP for deceptive and aggressive practices. The authority found that HP introduced inkjet and laser printer limitations, requiring authentication for non-original cartridges through firmware.

In September 2022, HP agreed to a $1.3 million settlement with Euroconsumers, a group of consumer organizations in Belgium, Italy, Spain, and Portugal. The settlement follows a May 2021 claim made by Euroconsumers. The settlement compensates consumers in those countries who faced issues with HP printers’ compatibility with third-party cartridges.

In February this year, HP settled a 2021 complaint filed by Radek Barnert and others regarding their instant ink program. The complaint highlighted delayed replacement cartridges and cartridges becoming non-functional upon subscription cancellation.

Our take on this: At one time the mantra was “all hail the great HP.” Those days are long gone and as this class action lawsuit progresses, HP’s reputation faces renewed scrutiny in the tech sector. This case taps into broader conversations surrounding consumer rights, transparency, and fair competition in an ever-evolving technological landscape. HP’s ability to address these legal challenges will not only impact its financial standing but could also shape the future practices of corporations in the tech sector.

Categories : World Focus

Tags : Class Action Complaint HP Legal USA

  • Mito Web advert July 2023
  • IR Italiana Web ad January 2021
  • Biuromax March 2024 Banner
  • GM Technology Web Ad March 2024
  • G&G Big & Bold Web banner January 2024
  • Static Control June 2022 Big & Bold Ad
  • TN Core April 2024 Web Banner
  • Ink Tank April 2024 Web Ads
  • Apex Web Banner April 2024
  • Cartridge Web April 2024 Web Banner
  • Altkin Web ad March 2024
  • ITP Web ad January 2021
  • Denner Feb 2024 Web Ad
  • CET Web ad December 2023
  • HYB Web banner Jan 2024
  • Zhono Web ad March 2024
  • PCL April 2024 Web Banner
  • ITP Web ad January 2021
  • PCL April 2024 Web Banner
  • Zhono Web ad March 2024
  • Altkin Web ad March 2024
  • HYB Web banner Jan 2024
  • Denner Feb 2024 Web Ad
  • CET Web ad December 2023
  • HYB Web banner Jan 2024
  • CET Web ad December 2023
  • Altkin Web ad March 2024
  • PCL April 2024 Web Banner
  • ITP Web ad January 2021
  • Denner Feb 2024 Web Ad
  • Zhono Web ad March 2024

The Recycler, Wittas House, Two Rivers, Station Lane, Witney, OX28 4BH, United Kingdom | Tel: +44 (0) 1993 899800 | Fax : +44 (0) 1993 226899
©2006-2023 The Recycler - Terms & Conditions - Privacy Policy including cookie use

Web design Dorset | Websites by Mark

The Recycler Subscribe Web ad January 2021
The Recycler Subscribe Web ad January 2021