The Recycler
  • Ninestar ink web banner
  • Katun March Web Advert 2021
  • Nubeprint Online 425x90
  • Biuromax Web ad May 2021
  • Static Dec 2021 Masthead

First-sale doctrine upheld by US Supreme Court

First-sale doctrine upheld by US Supreme Court

March 20, 2013

USSupremeCourtThe decision will prevent copyright owners from stopping imports and reselling of content sold abroad, which will have major implications for remanufacturing in the USA.

The ruling, in the case Kirtsaeng vs. John Wiley & Sons, corresponded to a Thai scientist living in the United States, Supap Kirtsaeng, who “imported textbooks lawfully printed overseas by a US publisher and sold them on eBay”. The publisher, Wiley & Sons, sued Kirtsaeng, and if they had won,  “content providers could have skirted [US] copyright laws and reasserted control over the use of sold products simply by moving their manufacturing overseas”.

Forbes features an opinion article from the Consumer Electronics Association’s President and CEO Gary Shapiro on the decision, which was made by the US Supreme Court six votes to three yesterday. The implications for cartridge remanufacturing in the USA, as well as many other industries, are that US consumers can “shop worldwide for […] copyrighted content” and “the legal purchaser of a copyright-protected item may dispose of that property any way he or she sees fit”, including reusing the product or reselling it.

Shapiro added that the decision “is a major victory for American consumers because it allows them to shop worldwide for their copyrighted content”, with the court explaining that the first-sale doctrine “makes sense in today’s interconnected world” by recognising that “consumers benefit from greater choice and lower prices when technology companies, libraries, used bookstores and retailers can import and sell products without having to ascertain that the US copyright owner approves of each further sale”.

Adding that “a geographical interpretation would subject many, if not all, of them to the disruptive impact of the threat of infringement suits”, the Supreme Court, Shapiro believes, has “preserve[d] the rights that the first-sale doctrine guarantees to manufacturers, retailers, libraries, consumers and the public at large”.

Shapiro noted that 30 years previously the Consumer Electronics Association had “fought and won a similar battle to preserve the first-sale doctrine” from Hollywood studios concerning VCR rentals and recordings, adding that he personally has spent “a good portion of the subsequent 28 years fending off efforts […] to restrict, tax or ban perfectly safe and useful technology”.

He concluded that the case “serves as an important reminder” that copyright in the United States “must be limited to its constitutional purpose of “promot[ing] the Progress of Science and useful Arts”, with the Supreme Court’s judgement comments yesterday highlighting that “American law […] as generally thought that competition, including freedom to resell, can work to the advantage of the consumer”.

Categories : World Focus

Tags : Legal Remanufacturing USA

  • Aster Web ad October
  • GM Web ad Jan 2022
  • Ninestar New Banner
  • Apex web ad May 2021 version 2
  • Static Big & Bold
  • GPI Jan 2022 Web advert
  • IR Italiana Web ad January 2021
  • Mito Jan 2022 Web ad
  • ITP Web ad January 2021
  • PCL Web ad January 2021
  • Zhono web ad
  • Adter Recruitment Web ad April 2021
  • CET Web ad September 2021
  • HYB Web ad February 2021
  • Printlife Web 300x250 Nov 2021
  • CTS Toner Supplies Web ad April 2021
  • Ohana July 2021 web advert
  • PCL Web ad January 2021
  • HYB Web ad February 2021
  • Adter Recruitment Web ad April 2021
  • Zhono web ad
  • Ohana July 2021 web advert
  • ITP Web ad January 2021
  • Printlife Web 300x250 Nov 2021
  • CTS Toner Supplies Web ad April 2021
  • CET Web ad September 2021
  • HYB Web ad February 2021
  • Printlife Web 300x250 Nov 2021
  • Adter Recruitment Web ad April 2021
  • CET Web ad September 2021
  • Zhono web ad
  • CTS Toner Supplies Web ad April 2021
  • ITP Web ad January 2021
  • PCL Web ad January 2021
  • Ohana July 2021 web advert

The Recycler, Wittas House, Two Rivers, Station Lane, Witney, OX28 4BH, United Kingdom | Tel: +44 (0) 1993 899800 | Fax : +44 (0) 1993 226899
©2006-2021 The Recycler - Terms & Conditions - Privacy Policy including cookie use

Web design Dorset | Websites by Mark

The Recycler Subscribe Web ad January 2021
The Recycler Subscribe Web ad January 2021